Indigenous Studies Program Faculty Annual Evaluation

Summary

This policy describes processes for annual evaluation of faculty in the Indigenous Studies Program.

Body

PRINT DISCLAIMER: Official version of this document is accessible in the online policy library at https://policyoffice.ku.edu/. Printed copies may not reflect the most recent updates.

DOCUMENT TYPE:

Policy

PURPOSE:

This policy describes processes for annual evaluation of faculty in the Indigenous Studies Program.

APPLIES TO:

Faculty in the Indigenous Studies Program

CAMPUS:

Lawrence

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

Introduction  

​I. Portfolio 

​II. Review Process 

​III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations 

​IV. Modifications 

​V. Performance Improvement Plans 

​VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases 

VII. Appeals

POLICY STATEMENT:

Introduction 

The Indigenous Studies Program envisions the annual review process as consisting of evaluative dimensions that assess the quality of faculty work and of formative dimensions that help faculty engage in a career-long process of reflection, adaptation, and growth. 

The Indigenous Studies Program engages multiple disciplines with varied epistemologies, methods, and terminology. Therefore, please feel free to explain how your accomplishments align with the language used n the ISP Promotion and Tenure Guidelines. You may offer alternative language and/or disciplinary context that demonstrates equivalent “rigor” in your field of study to the specific metrics identified below. 

Faculty members who have a primary or ‘home’ unit that is not ISP may elect to use their primary unit’s annual review process, including rubrics and forms, and transfer their self-evaluation into ISP’s process.  Overall, this annual evaluation is intended to offer opportunities to fully demonstrate your efforts, rather than increase burdens for faculty who have a ‘home’ unit outside of ISP.  

This Faculty Annual Evaluation Review process occurs within the context of the policies of the University of Kansas and the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences. This annual evaluation policy also operates within the broader framework of university engagement that demonstrates a commitment to the University IRISE values of integrity, respect, innovation, stewardship, and excellence. The following four paragraphs provide examples of how ISP faculty will demonstrate commitment to IRISE values. 

Faculty are expected to adhere to the general obligations of all University of Kansas employees. These include meeting deadlines for mandatory training, meeting deadlines for Statement of Substantial Interests reporting, replying to email in a timely manner, meeting deadlines for submitting self-reports to aid in the annual- evaluation process, responding to other reasonable requests for information from the Chair, and treating all members of the KU community with respect. 

Research: Faculty are expected to follow best practices set by their discipline and professional societies regarding research conduct. This includes, but is not limited to, the assignment of authorship and credit, the inclusion of and respect towards individuals in the research group, and the maintenance of high standards of professional and ethical conduct. With respect to university-wide procedures and processes, faculty are also expected to complete reporting or training as designated by the Office of Research. This includes, but is not limited to, Conflict-of-Interest Reporting, submission for project approval from Institutional Review Boards as appropriate, Responsible Conduct of Research Training, and completion of grant and project reports as requested by funding agencies. 

Teaching: Faculty are expected to complete teaching-related requests by designated deadlines. Such requests include, but are not limited to, submission of syllabi, submission of grades in Enroll and Pay, and submission of course materials such as Core 34 Signature Assignments. Faculty are also expected to post student grades to Canvas in a timely manner and to hold regular office hours. 

Service: Faculty are expected to attend department meetings regularly and contribute appropriately, attend departmental events such as departmental seminars and student-recognition ceremonies, participate in committees as assigned by the Chair, and participate in College or University-level committees to which they have been elected or appointed.” 

I. Portfolio 

The annual evaluation portfolio shall contain:  

  • A current CV; 
  • An employee annual summary using the adopted Faculty Annual Evaluation Form, which asks faculty members to provide narrative summaries and self-ratings for scholarship, teaching and service; 
  • Course syllabi and student evaluations for courses taught in the last twelve months; 
  • Publications, reports, and other scholarly products published in the last twelve months; and 
  • Any other documents as desired. 

The annual evaluation portfolio should provide sufficient information to allow the program director to evaluate whether the faculty member has met the expectations described in their annual work plan or workload assignment.  

II. Review Process 

Each faculty member must submit their portfolio materials by February 1st. 

Materials submitted by each faculty member as part of their annual evaluation portfolio will be reviewed by the program director using the performance expectations described in Section III.  

A written evaluation report shall be provided by February 15th  to each faculty member. At a minimum, the written evaluation report shall include the following:  

  • Ratings of performance in each area of responsibility; 
  • An overall rating of performance based on weighting in line with the faculty's allocation of effort percentages (e..g., 40% research, 40% teaching, and 20% service); 
  • Formative feedback commenting upon the faculty member’s performance in each area of responsibility; 
  • Any other information available to the Program Director that is material to the overall performance rating assigned to the faculty member; and,  
  • For cases in which a faculty member is assigned a rating of “poor” in any area of professional responsibility, the Program Director will also address the ways in which performance has been judged to be below expectations. 

Each faculty member shall have the opportunity to meet and discuss their written evaluation report with the program director prior to March 1st  

Annual Review Timeline Summary:  

  • February 1st – Initial Self-Review Due to Program Director 
  • Feb 15th  – Response to Faculty from Program Director via Letter 
  • March 1st  – Deadline for Faculty to share feedback and/or faculty response to Program Director’s evaluation letter, if desired. 
  • March 15th  – Final Submission Deadline to MyTalent by Program Director 
  • April 1st  - Workload Document for upcoming Academic Year Due to Program Director 
  • May 1st – Program Director emails response confirming receipt and acceptance of Workload Document 

III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations 

A. Rating Scale 

As part of the annual evaluation process, each faculty member shall receive a rating from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) for each area of professional responsibility as well as overall.  

The overall performance rating shall be weighted consistent with the faculty member’s annual workload allocation of effort, consistent with their Annual Workload document approved in May of the previous academic year. 

Consistent with the KU-UAKU memorandum of agreement article on evaluation (Article 16), any faculty member who refuses to participate in the annual evaluation process will receive an overall rating of Poor, with the exception of faculty members on approved leaves. 

B. Performance Expectations: Research / Scholarship / Creative Activity 

These metrics for performance ratings have been developed and approved by the ISP faculty. 

Rating

​ Description

Excellent (5)

Ongoing field/archival research, data collection 

​Plus one of the following: 

  • ​Publication of one peer-reviewed book (or subsequent editions) 
  • ​Editorship (Book, journal or research-to-practice reports) 
  • Publication of three peer-reviewed articles/book chapters (or equivalent research-to-practice reports) 
  • ​Major exhibits, films, media projects and/or digital humanities output 
  • ​Award for scholarship or other demonstrable impact (major review of book, citations of previously published scholarship, translations, invited lectures on research, other demonstrable impact of scholarship) 
  • ​Winning of major external fellowship or funding
Very Good (4)

​Ongoing field/archival research, data collection 

​Plus one of the following: 

  • ​Publication of one or two peer-reviewed articles/book chapters (or equivalent research-to-practice reports) 
  • ​Demonstrable impact (major review of book, citations of previously published scholarship, translations, invited lectures on research, other demonstrable impact of scholarship) 
  • ​Book contract received 
  • ​Winning of major University grant 
Good (3)

​Ongoing field/archival research, data collection 

​Plus one of the following: 

  • ​Submission of article for peer review 
  • ​Submission of grant applications 
  • Demonstrable progress on a large project 
  • ​Presenting scholarship at academic conferences 
Marginal (2)

Ongoing field/archival research, data collection 

  • ​Only minor publications (book reviews, encyclopedia entries, etc.) 
Poor (1) ​No evidence of research or scholarly activity through conferences, grants, data collection, or publications 

C. Performance Expectations: Teaching / Instructional Activity 

These metrics for performance ratings have been developed and approved by the ISP faculty. 

Rating Description
Excellent (5)

​Teaches normal load of classes per contract; syllabi demonstrate that course goals are clear; class content is current and appropriate for course; student evaluation ratings are consistently good; evidence of undergraduate and graduate advising commensurate with rank. 

​Evidence of strong progress towards previous year’s teaching goals (aligned with CTE Benchmark Rubric) 

Plus one of the following: 

  • ​Teaching award 
  • ​Evidence of exceptional syllabus/curriculum revision in service of Department or University objectives 
  • ​Leadership role in teaching on campus or in Department 
  • ​Teaches additional core course at Department request 
  • ​Evidence of exceptional quality and time commitment in the advising of graduate and undergraduate students 
  • ​Develops a brand-new course 
Very Good (4)

Teaches normal load of classes per contract; syllabi demonstrate that course goals are clear; class content is current and appropriate for course; student evaluation ratings are consistently good; evidence of undergraduate and graduate advising commensurate with rank. 

​Evidence of moderate progress towards teaching goals articulated in previous year’s Faculty Annual Review Form (aligned with CTE Benchmark Rubric).  

​Plus one of the following: 

  • ​Above average quality or time commitment in advising of undergraduate or graduate students. 
  • ​Involvement in university-wide teaching committees or workshops. 
  • ​Taking on a new course prep 
Good (3)

​Teaches normal load of classes per contract; syllabi demonstrate that course goals are clear; class content is current and appropriate for course; student evaluation ratings are consistently good; evidence of undergraduate and graduate advising commensurate with rank. 

​Evidence of progress towards teaching goals articulated in previous year’s Faculty Annual Review Form (aligned with CTE Benchmark Rubric) 

Marginal (2)

​Teaches normal load of classes per contract, but learning outcomes are not clear; student evaluations demonstrate consistent patterns of complaint; demonstrates need for improvement. 

​Minimal evidence of progress towards teaching goals articulated in previous year’s Faculty Annual Review Form (aligned with CTE Benchmark Rubric) 

Poor (1)

​May teach normal load of classes but syllabi and course goals are unclear; class content is not updated or appropriate for courses; student evaluations consistently rank in the lower half of the scale; little advising of undergraduate or graduate students; unsatisfactory peer teaching evaluations. 

​No evidence of progress towards teaching goals articulated in previous year’s Faculty Annual Review Form (aligned with CTE Benchmark Rubric) 

D. Performance Expectations: Service 

These metrics for performance ratings have been developed and approved by the ISP faculty. 

Rating Descriptions
Excellent (5)

​Fulfills normal service roles (attends meetings, mentors one GTA/GRA when funding permits, sits on one program, department or university committee) 

​Fulfills normal service outside University commensurate with rank, (examples include: reviews book manuscripts/proposals/articles/grant applications; performs tenure & promotion reviews; public talks, presentations, and collaborations; sits on committees (including editorial boards) in scholarly organizations, sits on local, regional, or state boards. etc. 

​And fulfills one of the following: 

  • Additional service leadership role within the University, (examples include: College or University committee, search committee in other Departments/programs, leadership roles in Centers) 
  • ​Effectively undertakes one leadership role in program or Department (DUS, DGS); officer in professional organization; journal editorship; other service leadership role with high workload. 
  • ​Recognized with an award for service 
  • Serves as a sponsor for student organization 
  • ​Service to Native Nations, professional orgs, Indian Orgs, TCUs, etc.  
Very Good (4)

​Fulfills normal service outside University commensurate with rank, (examples include: reviews book manuscripts/proposals/articles/grant applications; performs tenure & promotion reviews; public talks, presentations, and collaborations; sits on committees (including editorial boards) in scholarly organizations, sits on local, regional, or state boards. etc. 

​Fulfills normal Department service roles (attends meetings, mentors students 

​One substantial service commitment in University and one outside University (including service to Native Nations, professional orgs, Indian Orgs, TCUs, etc.) 

Good (3)

​Consistently engaged in normal service outside University commensurate with rank, (examples include: reviews book manuscripts/proposals/articles/grant applications; performs tenure & promotion reviews; public talks, presentations, and collaborations; sits on committees (including editorial boards) in scholarly organizations, sits on local, regional, or state boards. etc. 

​One substantial service commitment in University or one outside University. 

Marginal (2)

​Marginal fulfillment of normal Department service roles (does not routinely attend meetings, does not mentor GTA, lackluster service on Department committee) 

​Little engagement with field via review of articles, manuscripts, promotion and tenure files, sitting on committees in scholarly organizations, etc. 

Poor (1)

No service commitments outside Department.

Does not perform service

IV. Modifications 

A. For faculty members with joint appointments 

Faculty members with a joint appointment with another academic or university unit may use their other unit’s form instead of the ISP form. The Program Director will provide evaluation ratings in line with ISP performance expectations, making adjustments as necessary. 

B. For faculty members with split appointments 

Faculty members with a split appointment with another academic department may use their other unit’s form instead of the ISP form. The Program Director will provide evaluation ratings in line with ISP performance expectations, making adjustments as necessary. 

C. For faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements 

Faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements in place during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the guidelines described in Section III.A, including their Workload Document.  

D. For faculty members on sabbatical leave or research-intensive semester during the review period 

Faculty members who were on a sabbatical leave or a research-intensive semester during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the guidelines described in Section III.A, including their Workload Document.  

E. For faculty members on family or medical leave during the review period  

Faculty members who were on family or medical leave for a portion of the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect the change in Workload associated with the leave period. Faculty members who were on family or medical leave for the entirety of the review period are not required to submit portfolio materials and do not receive an annual performance evaluation.  

F. For faculty members on administrative leave or other forms of leave during the review period 

Faculty members who were on an administrative leave or other forms of leave during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect the change in Workload associated with the leave period. 

V. Performance Improvement Plans 

In the case that a faculty member receives an overall rating of marginal or poor, a performance improvement plan will be implemented.  

Performance improvement plans will be developed by the program director in consultation with the faculty member in accordance with the ISP Performance Improvement Plan Policy, completed in Fall 2026.  

The written Performance Improvement Plan will be shared with the faculty member within 45 days of the original evaluation. 

VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases 

Merit-based salary increases will be allocated in accordance with Article 20, part C, section 1 ("Merit Parameters") of the MOA, including the eligibility criteria stated there. Annual- review results will be translated and distributed into merit raises according to the following formula" . The percent-of-salary merit raise for each eligible bargaining unit member will be proportional to their score on the department rating scale of 1-5. For example, if a bargaining-unit member whose score is 3.6 will receive a raise of 1.2 percent of their base salary, then a bargaining unit member whose score is 4.5 will receive a raise of 1.5 percent of their base salary (because 4.5 divided by 3.6 is 1.25 and 1.25 times 1.2 is 1.5). Consistent with ratios computed in this way, percentages will be set as high as possible within the constraint of the total dollar amount of the merit pool. 

If merit increases were not given in the immediately preceding year(s), then the formula will be adjusted to include consideration of annual evaluation(s) for such immediately preceding year(s) if available. 

VII. Appeals 

Faculty members have a right to due process if disagreement arises during the evaluation process. If a faculty member wishes to appeal the outcome of their annual evaluation, the faculty member should follow the procedures described in the KU-UAKU memorandum of agreement (Article 17: Evaluations). If the program adds any non-union covered faculty members, they will follow a similar process of Appeal to the Chair, then Appeal to the CLAS Dean, and then Appeal to the Provost, without the involvement of UAKU. 

CONSEQUENCES:

​​Violations of this policy may result in a grievance filed through the UAKU grievance process.​

CONTACT:

Indigenous Studies Program
Director
indigenous@ku.edu
785-864-2660

RESPONSIBLE UNIT: 

College of Liberal Arts & Sciences

APPROVED BY:  

Dean of the College of Arts & Sciences

APPROVAL DATE:  

2026-09-30

EFFECTIVE DATE:  

2026-09-30

REVIEW CYCLE:  

1 year

RELATED STATUTES, REGULATIONS, AND/OR POLICIES:

Collective Bargaining Agreement between KU and UAKU 

CHANGE HISTORY:

11/19/2026: Uploaded to Policy Library to align with the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the University of Kansas and the United Academics of the University of Kansas (UAKU).

TITLE: 

Indigenous Studies Program Faculty Annual Evaluation

Details

Details

Article ID: 22172
Created
Thu 11/19/26 2:12 PM
Modified
Thu 11/19/26 2:12 PM