KU Libraries Faculty Annual Evaluation

PRINT DISCLAIMER: Official version of this document is accessible in the online policy library at https://policyoffice.ku.edu/. Printed copies may not reflect the most recent updates.

DOCUMENT TYPE:

Policy

PURPOSE:

This policy describes processes for annual evaluation of faculty in KU Libraries.

APPLIES TO:

Faculty in KU Libraries

CAMPUS:

Lawrence

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

Introduction  

​I. Portfolio 

​II. Review Process 

​III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations 

​IV. Modifications 

​V. Performance Improvement Plans 

​VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases 

VII. Appeals

DEFINITIONS:

MOA: Memorandum of Agreement Between the University of Kansas and United Academics of the University of Kansas, AFT-AAUP, AFL-CIO  

KBOR Manual: Kansas Board of Regents Policy Manual 

LFA: Library Faculty Assembly 

POLICY STATEMENT:

Introduction

​The University of Kansas, like most other research universities in the United States, has historically given greatest emphasis in the evaluation of Library Faculty to the quality of their performance in librarianship. This continues to be the case at KU. The KU Libraries expect that the expertise Library Faculty have developed through their professional performance and intellectual curiosity both can and should be shared with the profession at large in the form of significant service and an appropriate program of scholarship, both of which are subject to review by their professional peers. 

​The annual evaluation is intended to be developmental in nature and to assess each Library Faculty member's performance in relation to assigned responsibilities, approved workload allocations, goals, and annual work plan objectives, as developed in accordance with the Workload Policy. The evaluation process is designed to provide constructive feedback, support professional development, document progress toward individual and institutional goals, and establish an accurate record of performance. Annual evaluations may also inform decisions related to merit compensation, workload allocation, retention, promotion, tenure, post tenure, and other personnel matters. 

​This Evaluation Plan establishes the criteria, procedures, timelines, and instruments for annual evaluation of Library Faculty and is intended to be implemented in a manner consistent with Article 16 (Workload), Article 17 (Evaluations), and Article 20.C (Merit Raises) of the Memorandum of Agreement Between the University of Kansas and United Academics of the University of Kansas (MOA); applicable University policies; and the Kansas Board of Regents Policy Manual (KBOR Manual). 

​I. Portfolio 

​The annual evaluation portfolio shall contain: 

  • A current CV in PDF format 
  • An employee annual summary in Word format 
  • ​Any other materials (e.g., letters of support, reviews of work, instructional evaluations) that might assist in explaining the nature and quality of the Library Faculty member's work. (Optional) 

​The submitted CV should provide an outline of the Library Faculty member’s professional experience, assigned responsibilities, scholarly and professional accomplishments, service activities, honors and awards, instruction (if applicable), and other information relevant to the Library Faculty member's areas of responsibility. 

​The employee annual summary should be completed using the Libraries’ Faculty Evaluation Form and should include the following: a self-assessment of professional performance, research/scholarly activities, and service during the evaluation period, as identified in the annual work plan; an assessment of goals developed by the Library Faculty member in consultation with the supervisor for the evaluative year, including the extent to which those goals were accomplished; and proposed goals for the upcoming evaluation period. 

​Library Faculty members are encouraged to attach any letters, reviews of their work, or other supporting documentation that might assist in explaining the nature of their work.

​The annual evaluation portfolio should provide sufficient information to allow the supervisor to evaluate whether the Library Faculty member has met the expectations described in their annual work plan or workload assignment. 

​II. Review Process 

The evaluation process is determined by the members of the Library Faculty Assembly (LFA), in accordance with the MOA. Any changes to this process should be made prior to the calendar year in which they are to be applied. Employees who refuse to participate in the annual evaluation process will receive an overall rating of Poor, on the basis of non-participation, and will not be eligible for a merit salary increase and may face disciplinary action. 

​Each Library Faculty member must submit their portfolio materials no later than February 1 via a means specified by the Dean of Libraries. 

​Materials submitted by each Library Faculty member as part of their annual evaluation portfolio will be reviewed by the supervisor, using the performance expectations described in Section III. The supervisor assesses the Library Faculty member’s performance in each area of responsibility through the observation of and familiarity with the individual's work and the documentation provided by the Library Faculty member, available institutional data and supplemental documentation, along with any evaluative comments received from colleagues and/or recipients of service. The supervisor consults with the respective Associate Dean to discuss the review, when applicable. Any supplemental documentation utilized by the supervisor must be shared in full with the employee. 

​Written evaluative statements and a rating of performance for each area of responsibility will be provided by the supervisor to each Library Faculty member no later than March 1. An overall rating is assigned by the supervisor to indicate how well the Library Faculty member met performance expectations. The supervisor will provide an opportunity for a meeting with the Library Faculty member to occur no later than March 31 to discuss the evaluation and the Library Faculty’s proposed workload activities and goals for the next year. The evaluation documentation may include a brief summary statement of the discussion between the Library Faculty member and the supervisor pertaining to goals that support the Library Faculty member’s career trajectory, address unit needs, and an outline of plans for professional development during the next evaluation period. 

​At this point, the Library Faculty member’s Statement of Responsibilities is reviewed and revised as necessary, in accordance with Article 16 (Workload) of the MOA. Revised Statements of Responsibilities are to be forwarded to the administrative office and copies should be retained by the Library Faculty member and supervisor. Provisions within that documentation can be updated during the course of the following year if circumstances involving the Library Faculty member change substantially so as to have an effect on one or more of those documented items. 

​In accordance with KU’s Faculty Senate Rules and Regulations (FSRR) 6.5.1.2, the supervisor will consider the qualifications of tenured Library Faculty members below the rank of Librarian with a view toward possible promotion in rank in the future and, if appropriate, discuss the potential for initiating promotion procedures with the Library Faculty member. 

​The evaluation process includes the opportunity for Library Faculty members to add comments to the evaluation documentation as part of the official evaluation before the document is considered complete. In the event that the Library Faculty member disagrees with the outcome of their review, refer to the Appeals section of this policy. 

The Library Faculty member and supervisor finalize the evaluation and sign the resulting documentation no later than March 31. At this point, the annual performance evaluation process is completed, and neither party will add to or delete from the Annual Evaluation Report or its attachments. 

​Prior to the evaluation being finalized, the evaluation will be reviewed and signed by the Associate Dean (as applicable) and the Dean of the Libraries. 

​As the final step of the Annual Performance Evaluation Process, the supervisor ensures that all associated documentation, including electronic copies of the annual written evaluation report and attachments, meeting report, and any responses or supporting documentation from the bargaining unit member are filed in the faculty annual reporting system according to procedures provided by the Vice Provost of Faculty Affairs. 

​III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations 

​Expectations are similar for Library Faculty, although the Libraries recognize that the specific contributions of Library Faculty to the Libraries' mission will differ depending on career stage and rank, as well as the changing nature of the environment in which they work. As information specialists, Library Faculty are involved in the development and design of library resources, collections, and information systems; information management and organization; instructional and research consultation and support services; and administration and planning. Given the wide range of Library Faculty members’ responsibilities and unique work conditions, the supervisor’s in-depth understanding of the supervisee’s performance, as well as the Libraries' Criteria for Academic Ranks of Librarians, plays a key role in performance evaluation.  

​Across all areas of responsibility Library Faculty are expected to participate in University engagement that demonstrates a commitment to the IRISE University values of Integrity, Respect, Innovation, Stewardship, and Excellence, as defined by workload guidelines in alignment with Article 16 (Workload) of the MOA. Examples of University Engagement might include: treating all members of the KU community with respect; regularly attending and contributing to unit, team, or committee meetings; responding in a timely manner to email and reasonable requests for information; completing required university trainings or reporting; following best practices for research conduct in librarianship. Similarly, Library Faculty are expected to demonstrate a dedication to continuous learning, growth, and improvement through professional development. 

A. ​Rating Scale 

​As part of the annual evaluation process, each Library Faculty member shall receive a rating from poor to excellent for each area of professional responsibility as well as an overall rating on the same scale. 

​Quality is the primary consideration in each rating; quantity can support a rating but is not determinative on its own. The examples provided in subsequent sections are intended to be illustrative, not prescriptive. The ratings below should be applied as an evaluation of the individual’s performance, not in comparison to other Library Faculty members. 

​Descriptions of performance ratings from Article 17 (Evaluations) of MOA: 

  • ​Excellent performance substantially exceeds academic disciplinary and unit expectations in assigned areas of responsibility. 
  • ​Very Good performance exceeds academic disciplinary and unit expectations in assigned areas of responsibility. 
  • ​Good performance meets academic disciplinary and unit expectations in assigned areas of responsibility. 
  • ​Marginal performance falls below academic disciplinary and unit expectations in assigned areas of responsibility. 
  • ​Poor performance falls significantly below academic disciplinary and unit expectations in assigned areas of responsibility. 

​The overall performance rating shall be based on the aggregate of the assessments of the Library Faculty members’ areas of responsibility and shall be weighted in a manner consistent with the Library Faculty member’s annual workload allocation (Article 16, MOA) of effort, assigned duties, and the Libraries’ Annual Evaluation Policy. 

​For purposes of calculating the overall rating, performance ratings shall be assigned the following numerical values: 

  • ​Excellent = 5 
  • ​Very Good = 4 
  • ​Good = 3 
  • ​Marginal = 2 
  • Poor = 1 

​The overall score shall be calculated by multiplying the rating value for each area of responsibility by the percentage of workload allocation of effort assigned to that area and summing the results. 

​Example: 

  • ​Professional Performance (70%) = Very Good (4) 
  • ​Scholarship/Research/Creative Activity (20%) = Good (3) 
  • ​Service (10%) = Excellent (5) 
  • ​Overall score = (4 × .70) + (3 × .20) + (5 × .10) = 3.9

​The resulting overall score shall correspond to the following overall performance rating: 

  • ​4.50-5.00 = Excellent 
  • ​3.50-4.49 = Very Good 
  • ​2.50-3.49 = Good 
  • ​1.50-2.49 = Marginal 
  • ​1.00-1.49 = Poor 

​Consistent with the MOA Article 17 (Evaluations), any Library Faculty member who refuses to participate in the annual evaluation process, with the exception of Library Faculty members on approved leaves, will receive an overall rating of Poor. 

B. Performance Expectations: Research / Scholarship / Creative Activity 

​Library Faculty are expected to pursue a program of scholarship yielding high quality results, which include those works subject to dissemination and critical peer evaluation. In this way, Library Faculty will contribute to enhancing the profession of librarianship or a related area or a specialized subject area in which they conduct research/scholarly activities. All Library Faculty are expected to engage in consistent and sustained research/scholarly activities, commensurate with the annual workload allocation for research. The wide range of Library Faculty assignments at KU and the demands of 12-month appointments lead to variation in the type and amount of scholarly or creative activities in which they engage. The KU Libraries Promotion and Tenure policy and procedures offer additional guidance and examples of the kinds of research and scholarly contributions recognized in the discipline. 

​Excellent performance is characterized by a sustained, high-quality program of research/scholarly activity that substantially exceeds what is ordinarily expected for the individual's assigned effort. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

​Multiple substantive contributions disseminated through peer-reviewed or other highly selective venues within a single year, or documented evidence that the work has had a notable impact on the field (e.g., significant citation, adoption, award, or external recognition); 

​Sustained leadership in scholarship, such as service as a journal editor or editorial board member, or an invited/keynote presentation at a national or international conference; 

​Serving as principal/co-principal investigator on, or otherwise securing, an external grant or fellowship related to research/scholarship/creative activity 

​Very Good performance is characterized by a consistent record of research/scholarly activity that exceeds what is ordinarily expected for the individual's assigned effort. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Publication or acceptance for publication of a peer-reviewed journal article, book chapter, monograph, or comparable major scholarly work, or a substantial creative or curatorial project (e.g., an open educational resource, software tool, dataset, or exhibit); 
  • ​Presentation of peer-reviewed research at a national or international conference; 
  • ​Submission of a competitive external grant or fellowship proposal, or service as an editorial board member; 
  • ​Publication or acceptance for publication of a minor scholarly work (e.g., a poster session, non-peer-reviewed article, report, or annotated bibliography) together with demonstrated progress on a major work in development. 

​Good performance is characterized by consistent, sustained engagement in research/scholarly activity appropriate to the individual's assigned effort, with visible annual progress toward dissemination and peer assessment. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Active, documented progress on a research project or manuscript intended for dissemination (e.g., data collection, drafting, submission, or revision); 
  • ​Presentation at a regional, state, or local professional or scholarly meeting, or a poster session; 
  • ​Publication or acceptance for publication of a minor scholarly work such as a report, white paper, book review, or annotated bibliography, or a smaller-scale creative or curatorial project.

​Marginal performance is characterized by minimal or inconsistent engagement in research/scholarly activity relative to the individual's assigned effort that did not amount to a sustained program, such as: 

  • ​Little or no documented progress on a research project or scholarly activity during the year; 
  • ​An extended lapse in disseminating or seeking peer assessment of work; 
  • ​Repeated postponement of previously stated research goals without substantial cause. 

​Poor performance is characterized by a significant failure to engage in research/scholarly activity, such as: 

  • ​No evidence of research/scholarly activity or engagement during the year; 
  • ​Disregard of the assigned research/scholarly responsibility despite prior notice or a documented improvement plan; 
  • ​Failure to communicate with the supervisor regarding research progress, goals, or obstacles. 

C. ​Performance Expectations: Service 

​Library Faculty are expected to engage in service, including service to the academic discipline, the university, or the unit, as well as public service (insofar as it extends professional or discipline-related contributions to the community, the state, and/or the national or international community). Service to the university and/or department includes, but is not limited to, significant participation on unit and university committees, councils, and senates; service to KU as an officer in UAKU. Public service and service to the academic discipline includes, but is not limited to, contributions to scholarly and professional conferences and organizations, governmental boards, agencies, and commissions that are beneficial to such groups and individuals. 

​Excellent performance is characterized by distinctive professional contributions to the KU Libraries, to the University of Kansas, and/or to librarianship and related fields. Excellent service substantially exceeds ordinary expectations for the individual's assigned effort. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Significant service as a peer-reviewer and/or external reviewer for promotion and tenure files 
  • ​Serving as the chair of a committee or task force, or as an officer of a local, state, regional, national, or international professional organization 
  • ​Planning programs/conferences for professional organizations 
  • ​Developing a robust record of mentorship or a record 
  • ​Making regular presentations to community groups/civic organizations. 

​Very Good performance is characterized by a consistent record of service to the KU Libraries, the University of Kansas, and/or librarianship and related fields through active engagement in service activities. Very good service exceeds ordinary expectations for the individual's assigned effort.Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Actively participating in library, university, professional committees and task forces 
  • ​Consistent service as a peer-reviewer and/or external reviewer for promotion and tenure files 
  • ​Regularly contributing to programs/conferences 
  • ​Demonstrating increasing mentoring abilities 
  • ​Developing a record of presentations to community groups or civic organizations. 

​Good performance represents the standard level of expected service for annual evaluation. It is characterized by a record of service beyond assigned library responsibilities. Library Faculty participate in service activities that contribute to the KU Libraries, the University of Kansas, and/or librarianship. Good service meets expectations for the individual's assigned effort. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Participating in library, university, state, regional, national, or international professional committees and task forces 
  • ​Occasional service as a peer-reviewer and/or external reviewer for promotion and tenure files 
  • ​Making increasing contributions to professional organizations/conferences 
  • ​Demonstrating emerging mentoring capabilities. 

​Marginal performance is characterized by inconsistent or sporadic engagement with service opportunities that contribute to the KU Libraries, to the University of Kansas, and/or to librarianship and related fields.  Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Minimal participation in library, university, state, regional, national, or international professional committees/organizations, or conferences. 

​Poor performance is characterized by a failure to engage with service opportunities beyond their assigned library responsibilities. There is little to no evidence of service contributions to the KU Libraries, to the University of Kansas, and/or to librarianship and related fields.  Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • Lack of participation in library, university, state, regional, national, or international professional committees/organizations, or conferences. 

D. ​Performance Expectations: Professional Performance 

​Library Faculty professional responsibilities are individually differentiated, and it is impossible to enumerate all possible minimum standards of performance. However, broad demonstrations of the following allow supervisors and administrators in the Libraries to mark accomplishments and demonstrate that Library Faculty meet the minimum standards of professional performance. Effective Library Faculty members need to demonstrate competence, currency, creativity, and initiative. In some special cases, where a Library Faculty member teaches a for-credit class, they will be evaluated for their teaching effectiveness accordingly, either as part of their professional performance (if the instruction is not part of their position description) or as part of their teaching portfolio. 

​Excellent performance is characterized by performance that substantially exceeds unit and professional expectations in assigned responsibilities. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Fulfilling assigned duties at an exceptional level, consistently producing results that substantially exceed expectations for quality, timeliness, judgment, and effectiveness. 
  • ​Demonstrating highly developed understanding of the needs of library users in a research university and applying that understanding in ways that significantly strengthen assigned areas of responsibility and specialization. 
  • ​Providing leadership in discussion and decision-making on a broad range of library and related academic issues, contributing insight that advances priorities beyond the immediate assignment. 
  • Consistently staying abreast of current developments in library and information science and applying that knowledge creatively and effectively to address complex issues in the Libraries. 
  • ​Actively monitoring developments in related professional fields or academic disciplines and using that awareness to anticipate needs, improve services, or guide practice. 
  • ​Working with exceptional initiative and independence, applying professional and disciplinary knowledge to resolve complex issues and providing substantial guidance or mentorship to colleagues in related areas of specialization. 
  • ​Demonstrating consistently sound, strategic decision-making across the full range of assigned responsibilities, with clear awareness of how those decisions affect related areas of the Libraries. 
  • ​Applying skills, knowledge, and abilities in ways that significantly improve traditional services and emerging areas such as information literacy instruction, scholarly communications, access, preservation, or resource management. 

​Very good performance is characterized by performance that exceeds unit and professional expectations in assigned responsibilities. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • Fulfilling assigned duties very effectively, with results that regularly exceed expectations for quality, timeliness, judgment, or effectiveness. 
  • ​Demonstrating strong and continuing progress in understanding the needs of library users in a research university and applying that understanding effectively in assigned areas of responsibility and specialization. 
  • ​Participating actively and making meaningful contributions to discussion and decision-making on library and related academic issues, including matters beyond the immediate assignment. 
  • ​Keeping well informed about current developments in library and information science and using that knowledge to identify and address complex issues that arise in the Libraries. 
  • ​Monitoring developments in related professional fields or academic disciplines and applying relevant information appropriately to assigned responsibilities. 
  • ​Working with initiative and independence, applying professional and disciplinary knowledge to resolve complex issues and offering useful guidance to colleagues in related areas of specialization. 
  • ​Demonstrating sound decision-making across the range of assigned responsibilities, with a broader understanding of related assignments and priorities in the Libraries. 
  • ​Applying skills, knowledge, and abilities effectively to traditional library services and emerging areas such as information literacy instruction, scholarly communications, access, preservation, or resource management. 

​Good performance is characterized by performance that meets unit and professional expectations in assigned responsibilities. Good performance represents the standard level of expected achievement for annual evaluation. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Fulfilling assigned duties effectively, with results that meet expectations for quality, timeliness, judgment, and effectiveness. 
  • ​Demonstrating ongoing progress in understanding the needs of library users in a research university in the assigned areas of responsibility and specialization. 
  • ​Participating in and contributing to discussion and decision-making on a broad range of library and related academic issues—beyond the assignment. 
  • ​Showing progress in keeping abreast of current developments in the field of library and information science and applying this information in identifying and addressing the complex issues that arise in the Libraries. 
  • ​Monitoring developments in related professional fields or academic disciplines as appropriate. 
  • ​Working consistently with initiative and independence to apply the intellectual bases of library and information science, in addition to other relevant knowledge (e.g., in a discipline), to the identification and resolution of complex issues associated with the performance of the Library Faculty member’s responsibilities. Offering guidance to colleagues to identify and resolve issues in related areas of specialization. 
  • ​Demonstrating the ability to make sound decisions within the full range of responsibilities that make up the assignment, within a broader understanding of the assignments of colleagues in related areas of the Libraries. 
  • ​Applying skills, knowledge, and abilities to responsibilities that range from the traditional services of acquiring, accessing, and preserving resources to broader emerging areas in information literacy instruction and scholarly communications. 

​Marginal performance is characterized by performance that falls below unit and professional expectations in one or more significant aspects of assigned responsibilities. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Fulfilling assigned duties inconsistently or incompletely, with performance falling below expectations in one or more significant aspects of quality, timeliness, judgment, or effectiveness. 
  • ​Showing limited or uneven progress in understanding the needs of library users in a research university, resulting in gaps in assigned areas of responsibility and specialization. 
  • ​Participating only minimally or inconsistently in discussion and decision-making on library and related academic issues, including matters connected to or beyond the assignment. 
  • ​Not consistently keeping abreast of current developments in library and information science, limiting the ability to identify or address complex issues in the Libraries. 
  • ​Showing limited attention to developments in related professional fields or academic disciplines when such awareness is relevant to assigned responsibilities. 
  • ​Requiring more direction than expected to apply professional or disciplinary knowledge to complex issues and providing limited or inconsistent guidance to colleagues in related areas of specialization. 
  • ​Demonstrating inconsistent decision-making within assigned responsibilities or limited understanding of how decisions affect related areas of the Libraries. 
  • ​Applying skills, knowledge, and abilities unevenly to traditional library services or emerging areas, resulting in noticeable gaps in expected professional contribution. 

​Poor performance is characterized by performance that falls significantly below unit and professional expectations in assigned responsibilities. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Failing to fulfill assigned duties at an acceptable level, with performance falling significantly below expectations for quality, timeliness, judgment, or effectiveness. 
  • ​Demonstrating little evidence of understanding or responding to the needs of library users in a research university within assigned areas of responsibility and specialization. 
  • ​Rarely participating in or contributing meaningfully to discussion and decision-making on library and related academic issues, including issues connected to the assignment. 
  • ​Failing to keep abreast of current developments in library and information science in ways necessary to address responsibilities or complex issues in the Libraries. 
  • ​Not adequately monitoring relevant developments in related professional fields or academic disciplines when such awareness is expected for the assignment. 
  • ​Not demonstrating sufficient initiative, independence, or application of professional knowledge to identify and resolve complex issues associated with assigned responsibilities. 
  • ​Making decisions that are frequently unsound, incomplete, or poorly aligned with assigned responsibilities and related needs of the Libraries. 
  • ​Failing to apply expected skills, knowledge, and abilities adequately to traditional library services or emerging areas, resulting in significant deficiencies in professional contribution. 

E. ​Performance Expectations: Program Coordination / Administration 

​Program Coordination/Administration responsibilities might include supervision, budget oversight, strategic planning and direction setting, outcomes assessment, or other related duties. 

​Excellent performance is characterized by work that consistently substantially exceeds unit and professional expectations throughout the evaluation period. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Consistently demonstrating significant initiative in realizing new opportunities. 
  • ​Consistently acting in close alignment with unit needs and strategic priorities through planning, supervision, resource management, and/or assessment. 
  • ​Consistently providing exceptionally clear, appropriate communication. 
  • ​Consistently, proactively, and independently responding to challenges and concerns. 

​Very Good performance is characterized by work that consistently exceeds unit and professional expectations throughout the evaluation period. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Frequently demonstrating initiative in realizing new opportunities 
  • ​Frequently acting in close alignment with unit needs and strategic priorities through planning, supervision, resource management, and/or assessment. 
  • ​Frequently providing very clear, appropriate communication. 
  • ​Frequently and proactively responding to challenges and concerns. 

​Good performance is characterized by work that consistently meets unit and professional expectations throughout the evaluation period. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Realizing new opportunities when directed. 
  • ​Acting in alignment with unit needs and strategic priorities through planning, supervision, resource management, and/or assessment. 
  • ​Providing clear, appropriate communications. 
  • ​Responding to challenges and concerns.

​Marginal performance is characterized by work that regularly falls below unit and professional expectations during the evaluation period. Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Often failing to realize new opportunities when directed 
  • ​Often failing to act in alignment with unit needs and strategic priorities in planning, supervision, resource management, and/or assessment 
  • ​Often failing to communicate or provides unclear or inappropriate communication. 
  • ​Often failing to respond to challenges and concerns. 

​Poor performance is characterized by work that consistently fails to meet unit and professional expectations for substantial portions of the evaluation period.  Library Faculty members might demonstrate this by: 

  • ​Consistently failing to realize new opportunities when directed 
  • ​Consistently failing to act in alignment with unit needs and strategic priorities in planning, supervision, resource management, and/or assessment 
  • ​Consistently failing to communicate or provides unclear or inappropriate communication. 
  • ​Consistently failing to respond to challenges and concerns. 

​IV. Modifications 

A. ​For Library Faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements 

​Library Faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements in place during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the guidelines described in Section III.A. 

B. ​For Library Faculty members on sabbatical leave or research intensive semester during the review period 

​Library Faculty members who were on a sabbatical leave or a research intensive release during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the duration and nature of their sabbatical or research intensive release, as reflected in their annual allocation of effort consistent with the guidelines described in Section III.A and in accordance with the Workload Policy. 

​C. For Library Faculty members on family or medical leave during the review period 

​Library Faculty members who were on family or medical leave for a portion of the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the duration of their leave. Library Faculty members who were on family or medical leave for the entirety of the review period are not required to submit portfolio materials and do not receive an annual performance evaluation. 

D. ​For Library Faculty members on administrative leave or other forms of leave during the review period 

​Library Faculty members who were on an administrative or other forms of leave during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the nature and duration of their leave.

V. Performance Improvement Plans 

In the case that a Library Faculty member receives an overall rating of Poor, a performance improvement plan will be implemented in accordance with Article 17 (Evaluations) of the MOA. 

Performance improvements plans will be developed by the supervisor in consultation with the Library Faculty member and Associate Dean or Dean. The plan may include provisions for faculty development, mentorship, or other appropriate interventions aimed at promoting improved performance in the relevant area(s). The improvement plan will specify a time period of no less than 30 days and include requirements such as scheduled meetings and reporting, completion of training, and use of resources or tools that could support improvement of performance.  

​The written Performance Improvement Plan will be shared with the Library Faculty member within 30 business days of the completed evaluation with simultaneous transmission to UAKU, the Dean, the Office of Faculty Affairs and Human Resources. 

VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases 

​When funds for merit-based salary increases are available, increases will be allocated as follows. 

​Based on the provided merit pool for Library Faculty, merit-based salary increases will be allocated on an “equal percent” basis -- individuals with equal Overall Ratings will receive equal percentages of merit increases. Separate merit pools (when available) will be used for Library Faculty members in the bargaining unit and Library Faculty members not in the bargaining unit.  

The Overall Rating for a Library Faculty member is determined according to Section III A. If merit increases were not provided in the preceding year(s), the sum of a Library Faculty Member’s Overall Ratings from the current and preceding year(s) since the last merit raise will be used in determining merit-based salary increases.  

To determine salary increases, a Merit Share is calculated by dividing the Merit Pool by the sum of each merit-eligible Library Faculty member’s Overall Rating multiplied by their salary. Each faculty member’s salary increase is then calculated by multiplying the Merit Share by their Overall Rating and salary. 

​A simplified version of the Merit Share calculation would be:  

Merit Share = Merit Pool/Sum(Overall Rating x Salary) 

​“Sum” means the total obtained by adding together the “Overall Rating x Salary” amount for every merit-eligible Library Faculty member 

​The formal Merit Share is calculated as:

[EQUATION]

Where:

  • [Equation] = Merit Share
  • [Equation] = total Merit Pool
  • [Equation] = set of all eligible faculty
  • [Equation] =Overall Rating for faculty member
  • [Equation] = salary of faculty member

Individual salary increases are calculated as:

  • Salary Increase = Merit Share x Overall Rating x Salary

For Library Faculty member [Equation]:

​Library Faculty members are eligible for merit salary increase if they meet these criteria, consistent with Article 20 (Compensation) of the MOA. 

  • Appointed to a regular position in active payroll status 
  • Have a current Overall Rating of "Good" or higher 
  • Have not received formal documented disciplinary actions in the preceding annual evaluation period (defined in Article 21 (Discipline) in the MOA) 
  • Not on administrative leave for the entire annual evaluation period and thus not evaluated 

Consistent with the MOA Article 17 (Evaluations), any Library Faculty member who does not participate in the annual evaluation process, with the exception of Library Faculty members on approved leaves, will be ineligible for a merit salary increase. 

​VII. Appeals 

​Library Faculty members have a right to due process if disagreement arises during the evaluation process. Whenever possible, bargaining unit members are encouraged to discuss freely any problems or misunderstandings with concerned parties as they arise in an effort to avoid the necessity of activating the Appeal Procedures. A conscientious effort will be made to redress through this process and resolve difficulties at the lowest level possible. 

​Library Faculty members may appeal faculty evaluations of Marginal or Poor by (a) notifying the Libraries’ Human Resource Officer of an intention to do so and (b) following the procedures described in the MOA Article 17 (Evaluations).  UAKU will not be notified of appeals by Library Faculty members not in the bargaining unit. These steps should be taken within ten (10) calendar days of signing the Annual Review.

This appeals process does not apply to special circumstances such as procedural violations or failure of an individual to carry out their job duties and responsibilities, which are described in Article 22 (Grievance and Arbitration) of the MOA. 

CONSEQUENCES:

​​Violations of this policy may result in a grievance filed through the UAKU grievance process.​

CONTACT:

KU Libraries
Office of the Dean
1425 Jayhawk Blvd., Watson 502
Lawrence, KS 66046
785-864-8357

RESPONSIBLE UNIT:

Libraries

APPROVED BY:

Dean of Libraries

APPROVED ON:

2009-12-17

EFFECTIVE ON:

2009-12-17

REVIEW CYCLE:

1 year

RELATED STATUTES, REGULATIONS, AND/OR POLICIES:

Collective Bargaining Agreement between KU and UAKU 

CHANGE HISTORY:

11/19/2026: Updated to align with the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the University of Kansas and the United Academics of the University of Kansas (UAKU).
10/07/2025: Updated formatting.
05/30/2025: Updated links. 
04/04/2025: Migration to TeamDynamix from Drupal.
06/24/2024: Converted to live text page from PDF document.
06/21/2018: Revised by vote of the library faculty and approval of the Dean of Libraries.
11/05/2017: Revisedby vote of the library faculty and approval of the Dean of Libraries.
12/27/2012: Revised by vote of the library faculty and approval of the Dean of Libraries.
12/17/2009: Revised by vote of the library faculty and approval of the Dean of Libraries.

TITLE:

KU Libraries Faculty Annual Evaluation