Health, Sport, and Exercise Sciences Faculty Annual Evaluation

PRINT DISCLAIMER: Official version of this document is accessible in the online policy library at https://policyoffice.ku.edu/. Printed copies may not reflect the most recent updates.

DOCUMENT TYPE:

Policy

PURPOSE:

​​This policy describes processes for annual evaluation of faculty in the Department of Health, Sport, and Exercise Sciences​.

APPLIES TO:

​​Faculty in Department of Health, Sport, and Exercise Sciences​ 

CAMPUS:

Lawrence

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

Introduction  

​I. Portfolio 

​II. Review Process 

​III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations 

​IV. Modifications 

​V. Performance Improvement Plans 

​VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases 

VII. Appeals

DEFINITIONS:

HSES: Health, Sport, and Exercise Science

POLICY STATEMENT:

Introduction

​Each academic year, faculty members are evaluated by the Department of Health, Sport, and Exercise Science (HSES) Chair, with input from a seven person HSES Committee, in each area of professional responsibility (i.e., research, teaching, service, and administration, if applicable). In the sections that follow, the policies and procedures for the HSES faculty annual evaluation are detailed. After reviewing the following information, faculty are encouraged to discuss any questions with the current HSES Department Chair.  

I. Portfolio   

The annual evaluation portfolio shall contain:   

  • ​An up-to-date CV for the previous calendar year  
  • ​An employee annual summary: a list providing accomplishments in each area of workload allocation of effort during the previous calendar year. May include any interpretive comments and supporting data that the faculty member deems appropriate for evaluating performance.  
  • ​At least one Peer Evaluation of Teaching (Appendix 1)  
  • ​Any supplemental materials that document the faculty member’s achievements (including additional peer reviews of teaching, publications, service reports, etc.)  
  • ​Note: At the conclusion of each academic semester, students enrolled in your the faculty member’s course(s) will also be asked to complete an end-of-semester, online Student Survey of Teaching. The Chair will have access to quantitative ratings and qualitative student comments and will use these evaluations as a component of the annual performance review.

​The annual evaluation portfolio should provide sufficient information to allow the [chair / director / dean] to evaluate whether the faculty member has met the expectations described in their annual work plan or workload assignment. 

II. Review Process   

Each faculty member must submit their annual performance evaluation materials via email to the Chair on or before February 1st.   

​Materials submitted by each faculty member as part of their annual evaluation portfolio will be reviewed by a seven person HSES Committee (appointed by the Chair, featuring two members of each program and one at-large member) using the performance expectations described in Section III. Materials should be submitted to the Committee utilizing Faculty Insights as the primary data collection and reporting tool and the Chair will provide the final faculty member evaluation using the input from the Committee described above.

​A written evaluation report shall be provided by the chair to each faculty member on or before March 1. This report shall include: ratings of performance in each area of the faculty member’s professional responsibilities, an overall rating of performance, formative feedback commenting upon the faculty member’s performance in each area of responsibility, and any other information available to the chair that is material to the overall performance rating assigned to the faculty member.

Each faculty member shall have the opportunity to meet and discuss their written evaluation report with the chair on or before March 31. When the written evaluation report is shared with the faculty member, available dates and times to meet with the department chair will be provided to the faculty member. 

​Notes: 

  • ​Annual evaluation is not directly tied in any way to the tenure and promotion process.  
  • ​Goals and workload for the next academic year will also be discussed at the annual evaluation meeting (or at a separate meeting if faculty choose not to meet with the chair for the annual evaluation meeting) 
  • ​A rating of “Good” is the standard expectation for annual evaluation

III. Rating Scale and Performance Expectations

A. Rating Scale

​As part of the annual evaluation process, each faculty member shall receive a rating from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) for each area of professional responsibility as well as overall. An overall score will be calculated using the following formula = (% Effort Teaching) x (Teaching Score) + (% Effort Research/Scholarship) x (Research/Scholarship Score) + (% Effort Service) x (Service Score).  

​The overall performance rating shall be weighted consistent with the faculty member’s annual workload allocation of effort using the following guidelines: the weighting for the overall performance will match the contracted allocation of effort for each individual faculty member. Aspects of university engagement and professional development (definitions below) are integrated throughout each section below. 

​B. University Engagement 

​University engagement encompasses activities that demonstrate a commitment to the IRISE University values of: Integrity, Respect, Innovation, Stewardship and Excellence. For further details see the following. 

​C. Professional Development 

Professional development encompasses activities that demonstrate dedication to continuous learning, growth and improvement of the core academic competencies.

​Consistent with the KU-UAKU memorandum of agreement Article 17: Evaluations, any faculty member who refuses to participate in the annual evaluation process, with the exception of faculty members on approved leaves, will receive an overall rating of Poor.  

D. Performance Expectations: Research / Scholarship / Creative Activity  

Excellent (5): excellent performance in the area of research is characterized by   

  • Tenure-track or tenured faculty: Publishes four or more scholarly articles in refereed top-tier or mid-tier journals (tier is at the discretion of the committee). Peer-reviewed books nd peer-reviewed monographs will also be counted toward this total and the faculty member should include justification for the weight of each book/monograph based on the length and authorship level. Serves as the author on a presentation at a minimum of one national or international conference. 
  • Instructional Faculty: Demonstrates high-impact, sustained engagement across three or more activities, including at least one externally disseminated (e.g., publications, presentations, grants). These could also include activities that promote (i.e., presentations to external groups) or improve (i.e., presenting at leadership or industry conferences) their respective program.  

Very Good (4): very good performance in the area of research is characterized by   

  • Tenure-track or tenured faculty: Publishes three scholarly articles in refereed top-tier or mid-tier journals. Peer-reviewed books (excluding textbooks) and peer-reviewed monographs will also be counted toward this total and the faculty member should include justification for the weight of each book/monograph based on the length and authorship level. Serves as the author on a presentation at a minimum of one national or international conference.  
  •  Instructional faculty: Engages in two meaningful scholarly activities, including at least one externally disseminated (e.g., presentation, publication, grant activity). These could also include activities that promote (i.e., presentations to external groups) or improve (i.e., presenting at leadership or industry conferences) their respective program.  

​Good (3): good performance in the area of research is characterized by  

  • Tenure-track or tenured faculty: Publishes two scholarly articles in refereed top-tier or mid-tier journals. Peer-reviewed books (excluding textbooks) and peer-reviewed monographs will also be counted toward this total and the faculty member should include justification for the weight of each book/monograph based on the length and authorship level. Presents at or attends a regional, national, or international conference.  
  • Instructional faculty: Engages in two meaningful scholarly activities. These could include activities that promote (i.e., presentations to external groups) or improve (i.e., presenting at leadership or industry conferences) their respective program.  

Marginal (2): marginal performance in the area of research is characterized by   

  • Tenure-track or tenured faculty: Publishes one or more scholarly articles in refereed top-tier or mid-tier journals. Peer-reviewed books (excluding textbooks) and peer-reviewed monographs will also be counted toward this total and the faculty member should include justification for the weight of each book/monograph based on the length and authorship level. Marginal can also be satisfied by presenting at a national or international conference without a publication.  
  •  Instructional Faculty: Engages in one meaningful scholarly activity. These could include activities that promote (i.e., presentations to external groups) or improve (i.e., presenting at leadership or industry conferences) their respective program.  

Poor (1): poor performance in the area of research is characterized by 

  • engages in no research studies or scholarly activities during the year; makes no research or scholarly presentations at professional conferences; provides no evidence of other research or scholarly work.  

​Notes 

  • Intramural grants are encouraged and an important part of the research process.  
  • Funded extramural grants and research contracts will be evaluated with respect to movement between the above categories. Extramural grants that pay full indirect costs may move a faculty member up two categories. Submission of an external grant can also count as up to one publication each year. 
  • One book chapter can be counted toward the scholarly publication number each year. 
  • Each publication may only be counted once. Restated, you cannot count a publication in one year when it is in press and the next when it is published. 

E. Performance Expectations: Instructional Activity

Excellent (5): excellent performance in the area of teaching is characterized by fulfillment of the first item, plus any one of the remaining two:  

  • Course survey results will have a response of Almost Always of 90% or higher for a majority of the survey items (using the currently adopted KU course surveys). If the survey utilized by KU is altered, 90% of Almost Always or the equivalent is required on the majority of the items. 
  • Provides at least two other types of evidence of innovative instructional or evaluation techniques and enhancements of teaching and/or student learning (this does not include the standard Student Survey of Teaching results)  
  • Provides evidence of one-on-one mentoring to more than one student, such as, but not limited to, through mentoring of dissertations, theses, and independent studies  

Very Good (4): very good performance in the area of teaching is characterized by fulfillment of the first item, plus any one of the remaining two:  

  • Course survey results will have a response of Almost Always of 80% or higher for a majority of the survey items (using the currently adopted KU course surveys). If the survey utilized by KU is altered, 80% of Almost Always or the equivalent is required on the majority of the items. 
  • Provides at least one other type of evidence of innovative instructional or evaluation techniques and enhancements of teaching and/or student learning (this does not include the standard Student Survey of Teaching results)  
  • Provides evidence of one-on-one mentoring to more than one student, such as, but not limited to, through mentoring of dissertations, theses, and independent studies  

Good (3): good performance in the area of teaching is characterized by fulfillment of both items:  

  • Course survey results will have a response of Almost Always of 75% or higher for a majority of the survey items (using the currently adopted KU course surveys). If the survey utilized by KU is altered, 75% of Almost Always or the equivalent is required on the majority of the items. 
  • Provides at least one other type of evidence of innovative instructional or evaluation techniques and enhancements of teaching and/or student learning (this does not include the standard Student Survey of Teaching results)  

Marginal (2): marginal performance in the area of teaching is characterized by meeting:  

  • Course survey results will have a response of Almost Always of 75% or higher for a majority of the survey items (using the currently adopted KU course surveys). If the survey utilized by KU is altered, 75% of Almost Always or the equivalent is required on the majority of the items. 

Poor (1): poor performance in the area of teaching is characterized by:  

  • Scores on the Student Survey of Teaching are below the 75% threshold discussed in the above categories 
  • Provides no evidence of innovative instructional or evaluation techniques and enhancements of teaching and/or student learning  

F. Performance Expectations: Service  

Excellent (5): excellent performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • Substantive service to the profession/discipline (examples include serving in a leadership role or senior board member for an academic journal, leader in a community organization that is relevant to professional role, leadership in a campus organization, and/or a conference leadership role); and  
  • Actively and consistently serving on one university-level committee and one or more school or department-level committee OR actively and consistently serving on two or more school or department-level committees.   

Very Good (4): very good performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • Substantive service to the profession/discipline (e.g., reviewer for multiple journals, board member, conference role); and
  • Serve on one institutional level (university, school, or department) committee  

Good (3): good performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • At least one service contribution to the profession/discipline (reviewer, board member, etc.); and  
  • Service on at least one institutional committee (university, school, or department).  

Marginal (2): marginal performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • Limited or inconsistent service to the profession/discipline; and/or  
  • Minimal participation in a single institutional committee, with little evidence of substantive contribution or engagement.  

Poor (1): poor performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • No service to the profession/discipline; and  
  • No meaningful participation in institutional service activities.  

G. Performance Expectations: Program Directors/Coordinators (if applicable to faculty member)  

Excellent (5): excellent performance in the area of program direction / coordination is characterized by   

  • ​Effective and sustained leadership of the program, including successful coordination of curriculum, scheduling, and program operations;  
  • ​Proactive strategic contributions (e.g., program development, assessment improvements, recruitment efforts, accreditation support, if applicable); and  
  • ​Consistent, high-quality execution of administrative duties (e.g., student issues, petitions, course approvals), with evidence of impact, innovation, or program improvement.  
  • Consistent programmatic goal setting and evaluation of outcomes 

Very Good (4): very good performance in the area of program direction / coordination is characterized by

  • ​Strong and reliable coordination of program responsibilities, including scheduling, program oversight, and evaluations;  
  • ​Active contribution to program maintenance and improvement; and  
  • ​Consistent and effective handling of student issues, petitions, and administrative processes, with minor evidence of initiative beyond baseline duties.  

Good (3): good performance in the area of program direction / coordination is characterized by

  • ​Adequate fulfillment of core administrative duties, including scheduling, program coordination, and required reporting; and  
  • ​Timely handling of routine responsibilities (e.g., student concerns, course approvals, system updates), meeting baseline expectations without significant leadership or innovation.  

​Marginal (2): marginal performance in the area of program direction / coordination is characterized by

  • ​Inconsistent or incomplete fulfillment of administrative duties;  
  • ​Delays or gaps in required tasks (e.g., scheduling, student petitions, reporting); and/or  
  • ​Limited engagement in program coordination or responsiveness to stakeholders.  

​Poor (1): poor performance in the area of service is characterized by   

  • ​Failure to carry out core administrative responsibilities;  
  • ​Significant lapses in program coordination, student support, or required processes; and  
  • ​Lack of responsiveness or reliability, negatively affecting program functioning.  

IV. Modifications

A. For faculty members with joint appointments  

​Faculty members with formal joint appointments will be evaluated through their primary department, with structured input from the secondary unit(s). Expectations for teaching, scholarship, service, and administrative responsibilities will be proportional to the formally assigned distribution of effort across units. The primary department is responsible for issuing the final annual evaluation, incorporating documented input from the secondary unit regarding performance in assigned responsibilities. Evaluation standards shall reflect the faculty member’s agreed-upon workload allocation, and unit heads will consult to ensure a fair, consistent, and coordinated review.

Faculty members who engage in activities for another unit without a formal joint appointment (e.g., occasional teaching, committee service, or collaboration) will be evaluated solely within their home department. Such contributions will be considered supplemental service or scholarly activity, provided they do not materially alter the faculty member’s primary workload assignment. These activities do not constitute a joint appointment and will not result in a proportional redistribution of expectations unless formally approved.  

B. For faculty members with split appointments

​Faculty members with formal split appointments with a research center will be evaluated with the same modifications described in section above.

C. For faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements  

​Faculty members with differential allocation of effort agreements in place during the review period will have their overall performance rating adjusted to reflect their allocation of effort consistent with the guidelines described in section above.

D. For faculty members on sabbatical leave or research-intensive semester during the review period

Faculty members on sabbatical or a research-intensive semester will be evaluated primarily on activities and outcomes associated with the approved leave plan. Expectations in teaching and service will be reduced or eliminated consistent with the approved workload.

E. For faculty members on family or medical leave during the review period

​Faculty members on family or medical leave for a portion of the review period will have expected performance pro-rated based on time in active service. Evaluation will consider only the period of active work and will be conducted in the context of approved leave and any modified duties, emphasizing the quality and impact of contributions rather than quantity, with no penalties for reduced productivity attributable to approved leave. Faculty members who were on family or medical leave for the entirety of the review period are not required to submit portfolio materials and do not receive an annual performance evaluation.  

V. Performance Improvement Plans  

A performance improvement plan (PIP) will be implemented if a faculty member received an overall rating of “poor” or a rating of “poor” in any of the areas of responsibility.   

Performance improvements plans will be developed by the chair in consultation with the faculty member. The plan may include provisions for faculty development, mentorship, or other appropriate interventions aimed at promoting improved performance in the relevant area(s).

The written Performance Improvement Plan will be shared with the faculty member within 30 days of the original evaluation.

VI. Merit-Based Salary Increases

Materials submitted by each faculty member as part of their annual evaluation portfolio will be reviewed by a seven person HSES Committee (appointed by the Chair, featuring two members of each program and one at-large member) using the performance expectations described in Section III to first determine a rank order for merit for each classification of faculty. The rankings will be determined using the following formula: Overall Score = (% Effort Teaching) x (Teaching Score) + (% Effort Research/Scholarship) x (Research/Scholarship Score) + (% Effort Service) x (Service Score). For those with administrative/director appointments, the percentages will be updated to reflect their workload. These rankings will be submitted to the Chair as recommendations for merit distribution. Chair recommendations for merit-based pay increases are based on and relative to annual overall performance ratings, with those rated as “Excellent” eligible for the largest increases. 

Consistent with the KU-UAKU memorandum of agreement Article 17: Evaluations, any faculty member who does not participate in the annual evaluation process, will be ineligible for a merit salary increase.

VII. Appeals   

Faculty members have a right to due process if disagreement arises during the evaluation process. If a faculty member wishes to appeal the outcome of their annual evaluation, the faculty member should follow the procedures described in the KU-UAKU memorandum of agreement Article 17: Evaluations. Overall ratings of “good” and above cannot be appealed. 

If a faculty member who is not covered by UAKU wishes to appeal the outcome of their annual evaluation, the faculty member may file a formal written appeal using the same procedures described in Article 17 of the MOA; however, UAKU will not be notified of appeals by non-union-covered faculty members 

CONSEQUENCES:

​​Violations of this policy may result in a grievance filed through the UAKU grievance process.​

CONTACT:

Department of Health, Sport, and Exercise Sciences

RESPONSIBLE UNIT: 

School of Education & Human Sciences

APPROVED BY:  

Dean of the School of Education & Human Sciences

APPROVAL DATE:  

2026-10-13

EFFECTIVE DATE:  

2026-10-13

REVIEW CYCLE:  

1 year

BACKGROUND:

Approved by Department vote on 10/13/2026.

RELATED STATUTES, REGULATIONS, AND/OR POLICIES:

Collective Bargaining Agreement between KU and UAKU 

CHANGE HISTORY:

11/20/2026: Updated to align with the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the University of Kansas and the United Academics of the University of Kansas (UAKU).

TITLE: 

Health, Sport, and Exercise Sciences Faculty Annual Evaluation